Commanders, a wargame digest

Commanders, a wargame digest

Menu

Choosing a figures scale!

Decisions, decisions, decisions for the figure collection.

To conclude the posts that have appeared here since the middle of last year, looking at this subject, it looks like I am finally ready to jump …. One way or the other!

Despite wanting to organise my collection into a single figure scale and terrain scale, I have spent months (years) going back and forth, agonising on whether to collect in the smaller or larger scales and this has spread my efforts too thinly as I continue to cover collect and paint each period in multiple scales. 

You, dear reader, will no doubt roll your eyes in despair at the tussle that it has become, I have changed my mind a hundred times (a day) and the whole plot could have been made into a major tear jerking movie :-)

In September, I single-mindedly assaulted my boardgame shelves to ruthlessly reduce the number of differing rulesets and struck upon the solution of having just one series system for each of the major periods that interested me. This has had a very significant impact on the boardgame side of things, as I now have much fewer rule systems overall to become entangled with.

There is a link in the Resource Section (below) that discusses the ‘Taming of the Boardgame Collection’. It does have some interesting aspects that might help your shelves!

Anyway, it has been the recent paring back of the boardgames collection that has pushed me (finally!) towards a solution for the figures and figure rules dilemma.

So without further ado ……. Drum roll …… I have pinched my nose, held my breath and just jumped in and decided upon scale and a much narrower range of rules and the winner is ….. 28mm for everything except WWII which will be 20mm (1/72) and all of these figures can share 20mm terrain, which also has the convenience of being able to draw upon the rail modellers HO/OO scale buildings.

Some of you may remember that we have been here before and perhaps the least said about that the better.

There of course now needs to be plans of how this is all going to proceed …. I mean there would have to be, wouldn’t there :-)

These are the initial armies that I will receive immediate attention - unfortunately, doing both sides will make for slower progress;

1066 Norman / Anglo-Saxon pairing

Wars of the Roses Lancastrian / Yorkist pairing 

1809 Napoleonic French / Austrian pairing

American Civil War Confederate / Union pairing

WWII Tactical 1/72 German / Russian (1943) pairing

That only leaves English Civil War and American War of Independence as a ‘want’ and so, sensibly, they get pushed into the future.

Each of the 5 pairings of the armies listed above will be taken to ‘Pocket Army’ size in the first instance, giving combined arms and generally six units per army, allowing for some smaller games. 

The expectation is that once each army has been established, they will be worked on at a more leisurely pace to bring them up to double size. A pick of up to twelve units per side per game seems like a good place for the armies to sit to give me the sort of games that I like, at around say three brigade sized type armies per side.

Terrain will be worked on and each army paring should be able to have at least one Built Up Area (BUA) with buildings specific to their time frame.

Choosing rules

Having identified the periods of choice, the corresponding rulesets needed to be selected and it must be said, like many, I have a fair number to choose from.

Harking back to the process that I have just used to streamline the boardgame collection, I am going to apply the same single-minded series style process here.

All of the periods I favour (except WWII) fall within the time frame covered by what could be thought of as the Warlord Games’ trilogy of the Black Powder systems, these being, Black Powder, Pike & Shotte and Hail Caesar and so it is here that the axe will fall, with these rules and their various supplements being kept.

Not only does this cut rule systems down to just three sets, but these three books are themselves heavily inter-related. Know one of them properly and you will know 85% of the others.

Yes, there are pros and cons to these rule sets, but harsh streamlining does what harsh streamlining does and this will at least stop me flip-flopping around the world of rulesets ….. for now at least :-)

Edit - I am also working on my own rule sets and more of my gaming is making use of them. I am not saying they are better or that other systems have failed me, its just I like what is in them … obviously!

I have been working with them for a number of years, so they are both familiar and fairly tight now. Recently I have sent the Napoleonic and ACW sets off to one of these print on demand companies and had each printed out as a proper rules book, with nice photos etc.

They are still being tweaked and though I don’t like the idea of writing update notes in these printed books, they are just tools (he says) and it is nice to have them in a ‘proper’ looking format. They have cost me between £10.50 and £14.40 to have printed (post free), so doing a new updated version every now and then is acceptable, especially asI have mostly stopped buying commercial rules. 

Smaller armies?

For WWII, I have warmed to Rapid Fire Reloaded and have already started basing infantry for that system, so they are also in the final mix.

Taken together, all of this should bring a much tighter focus to the figure side of my gaming. Storage will be acceptable, painting will be more pleasurable with the bigger scale and a bit of modelling along the way can be enjoyed. 

These smaller armies should deliver relatively short games (under 2 hours) - a few of my recent games have been running for at least double that, putting a noticeable strain on my back and causing discomfort for the following couple of days - so all of these plans are not just do-able, but for the good.

And then of course there is the inspiration that comes from other gamer’s tables - there is a video link in the Resource Section (below) from a demo game by the League of Augsburg. Their table is what I see my games looking like in my minds eye :-).

Should it stay or should it go!

Once I had decided to approach the question of figure scales and rules with the same ruthlessness that I did with the boardgames, the obvious conclusion was that with a decision made of what to keep, everything else would have to go and that is where the real conundrum sat - If I had chosen the smaller scale, that would mean the 28mm Wars of the Roses stuff going and the 28mm 1066 not being built and I just couldn’t travel that route and in the end, it became the deciding factor.

I have always said that the question of what to keep should be turned upon its head and instead the question should be ‘what could I allow to go’. There is a strong argument for wanting to keep both large and small scales and many gamers do, but in the end, I knew that it would come down to a heart over mind decision. I have likely made the emotional choice, rather than the sensible choice for my circumstances …. but in the words of the greatest of philosophers - Bollocks to it! 

I am fortunate that most of this kit is already in my possession, some in raw metal, but most is plastic, still on the sprue, due to some over-buying during Covid Lockdown, so the plans are not really looking at any new financial commitment, rather, there should be a release of funds as the other stuff gets sold off.

And so at last!

This all gives a definitive framework for the brutal disposal of ‘everything else’, whether by sale, donation or bin! making space both physically and mentally. 

I must say, this sudden activity in sorting out the boardgames and the figures in one fell swoop has come as something of a surprise and has been seriously cathartic in its own way. I am back to embracing the simple principle that all of this wargaming thing should be a simple joy.

I don’t want distracting multiple rulesets, I don’t like painting, I don’t want dozens of battalions and I prefer shorter games, certainly for figures. I do like playing games with things that look pretty and that are just a pleasure to own for their own sake. So there it is, a decision! I can now come out of my bunker!

There will obviously be a bit of a lag while this all gets jacked up, but the reader should then start to see some of this stuff drifting onto the table as a plan most excellent is executed :-)

Thanks for accommodating the recent self indulgent posts on hobby restructuring. The truth is, none if it is important enough to justify public consumption, but if it turns a light on for any one else, then good.

Resources

Video by League of Augsburg LINK

https://youtu.be/FbemdT1cN24?si=2edcisXco0SH9iv-

My sister webspace ‘COMMANDERS’ is being re-configured to showcase various figure and boardgame systems that I am enjoying and gives a flavour of where current projects are up to. Link.

https://commanders.simdif.com

Cookie settings
X
This site uses cookies to offer you a better browsing experience.
You can accept them all, or choose the kinds of cookies you are happy to allow.
Privacy settings
Choose which cookies you wish to allow while you browse this website. Please note that some cookies cannot be turned off, because without them the website would not function.
Essential
To prevent spam this site uses Google Recaptcha in its contact forms.

This site may also use cookies for ecommerce and payment systems which are essential for the website to function properly.
Google Services
This site uses cookies from Google to access data such as the pages you visit and your IP address. Google services on this website may include:

- Google Maps
Data Driven
This site may use cookies to record visitor behavior, monitor ad conversions, and create audiences, including from:

- Google Analytics
- Google Ads conversion tracking
- Facebook (Meta Pixel)